Rex Wolfley

Civic’s ‘Pill’ a strong dose

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By John Lyle Belden

What appears to be just a pop “jukebox musical” turns out to be one of the most important theater works in central Indiana this year.

The Booth Tarkington Civic Theatre presents Alanis Morissette’s “Jagged Little Pill: The Musical,” directed by Civic’s Executive Artistic Director, Michael J. Lasley. The show features all 12 songs on Morisette’s 1995 album – a breakthrough both in international stardom and psychologically as she bared raw emotions in her break from dance-pop (influencing the outspoken and genre-bending women vocalists and singer-songwriters who followed).  The lyrics are all hers, with music co-written by Glen Ballard. The musical also includes eight songs from her other albums, a repurposing of her “Uninvited” (originally on a film soundtrack), and two new songs for this production.

Perfectly matching Morrisette’s style, the book of the musical is by author and screenwriter Diablo Cody. The meshing of lyrics to a coherent plot is not only the most successful since “Mama Mia,” but also delivers impactful messages in a powerful work that stands in a very sum-greater-than-parts way. The uncompromising nature of both Morrisette and Cody comes through in that while this should be necessary viewing for all high schoolers, the language and content keep this strictly PG-13 at least. The circumstances and emotional heft of some scenes even shook adults in the audience.

The story of the musical centers on the Healy family of suburban Connecticut. Mary Jane (Abigail Okerson) stays at home, recovering from a car accident, while husband Steve (Rex Wolfley) works extra hours in Manhattan to keep them afloat. Son Nick (Cole Hurt), a high school senior, has just been accepted to Harvard, while younger adopted sister Frankie (Desirae Brown) deals with being a Black girl in likely the most White circumstances in America. Fortunately, she has a girlfriend, Jo (Kelsey McDaniel), who couldn’t be more out but whose mother insists being gay is a “phase.”

With the arrival of Christmas break, Nick is invited by fellow members of the school swim team to a party (unsupervised, of course) at a classmate’s house. Frankie also goes, invited by new classmate Phoenix (Jacob Schilling), who admired her poetry; they quickly leave, neither liking all the noise and alcohol. Bella (Bridget Dean), who takes on an up-for-anything attitude to fit in, is last seen with popular and well-connected Andrew (Keaton McDorman).

Meanwhile, Mary Jane has been feeling herself drifting apart from her husband, as well as in constant pain as her meds aren’t working anymore. The pharmacy won’t fill another prescription, so she found pills elsewhere, while promising herself that she’ll start cutting her dose.

The next day, news of Bella’s sexual assault – cruelly spread by photos on social media – rocks the school and affects the Healy family in various ways. Everyone’s façade of perfection is shattering.

Like in life, this show has a number of lighter moments as well, aided by the more upbeat songs. The issue of irony in “Ironic” is thoroughly dealt with in a way that lets us know all involved understand how ironically unironic the song is, and that perhaps we should all just lighten up about it. “Head Over Feet” gets an appropriately charming moment as well. Still, this pill is indeed jagged, and the cast are fortunately all capable of the trademark Alanis “wail,” put to great use by McDaniel in “You Oughta Know” and Oakerson in an unforgettable performance of “Uninvited.”

The ensemble of Chloe Boelter, Ashley Chisler, Drew Hedges, Courtney Krauter, Halle Massingale, Joseph Massingale, DaSean McLucas, Larkyn Muth, Aiden Powell, Jade Radford, Matthew Sumpter, and Mary Kate Tanselle fill various roles, and frequently appear on stage as chorus. Aided by Kasey Walker Lewellyn’s excellent choreography, such scenes amplify the impact of the songs without being visually crowded. The ensemble work really shines in the appropriately disturbing new song, “Predator.”

Music director is Brent Marty, with orchestra managed by Al French. Sydnie Blair is stage manager, assisted by Chrysa Conley.

Lasley noted that, of course, no one had any idea when this musical was scheduled that the topic of public shame of and accountability for sexual assault would become as timely as it has in recent weeks. Still, understanding that it has always been an ongoing concern, he said from the first rehearsals onward he took extra measures for all cast members to feel the stage is a safe space. Actors who spoke after the performance expressed gratitude for this. Intimacy director Emily Rogge Tzucker, who has worked regularly with Civic, helped ensure that the performers would stay professional and not take on the trauma of their characters.

The sense of safety extends to the audience as well. Civic coordinated with Prevail, a local organization that supports victims of crime and abuse, to have one of their staff in the lobby during every performance of “Jagged Little Pill.” Audience members are free to leave during the show if they feel upset or overwhelmed and will have someone to talk to.

Performances are Friday through Sunday, Oct. 9-11, and Friday and Saturday, Oct. 16-17, in the Tarkington at the Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in downtown Carmel. Get info and tickets at civictheatre.org or thecenterpresents.org.

New dinner theatre celebrates Broadway

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By John Lyle Belden

This year there is a new place for dinner and a show, in an old, familiar building. The Murat Shrine Club (north side of the historic building that now houses the Old National Center) hosts Downtown Dinner & Theatre. We got to experience it for the current production of “Broadway Off Broadway.”

After the opportunity to dine like a Potentate at a small buffet, patrons were ushered upstairs to the intimate cabaret stage for a musical revue.

The theme, of course, is various songs of Broadway hits, performed by a very talented troupe: Alicia Barnes, Alexis Koshenina, Jennifer Simms, Parker Taylor, and Rex Wolfley. Company artistic director Simms directed the show and Wolfley wrote its “book,” so to speak, with input from the others.

The narrative structure is built on our cast finding themselves in a “classroom” with magical properties, instructed by the disembodied voice of a spirit of musical theatre, “BOB,” by Ty Stover of StageQuest Theatrical Services. This impish entity helps to bring out the self-confidence, vocal and otherwise, in each of our singers.

All the while, we are treated to exceptional renditions of around 20 showtunes. Some of them you might expect – from Sondheim, Andew Lloyd Weber, Rogers and Hammerstein, etc. – plus some wonderful surprises. (There were whispers of, “What was that one from?”) Look for something from “Chess,” “Wicked,” “In the Heights,” “Spring Awakening, “Dear Evan Hansen,” and even this year’s Tony winner, “Maybe Happy Ending.”

Performances are sharp throughout, infused with good humor – especially as they act manipulated by BOB invisibly positioning them for numbers and dance breaks. Taylor, quickly becoming one of Indy’s biggest stage talents, is particularly good at this. While all are well-cast vocally (and their strengths were taken into account in song selection), Koshenina exhibits show-stopping power and range.

We give this “class” high marks. You can attend Friday through Sunday, Sept. 12-14, Friday the 19th, or matinee or evening Saturday the 20th, at 510 N. New Jersey St., downtown Indianapolis. Get info and tickets at downtowndt.com.

Civic gets ‘Curious’ with story of mystery and maths

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By John Lyle Belden

One nice thing about the Booth Tarkington Civic Theatre production of “The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time” (by Simon Stephens, based on the Mark Haddon novel) is that instead of a realistic looking dead dog in the middle of the stage, there is a chalk-outline style silhouette – with the garden fork stuck in it. Can’t avoid that detail as the dog, Wellington, is indeed dead.

But this play isn’t really about the dog.

The canine crime, however, is what starts Christopher Boone, a teenager in Swindon, England, who is definitely on the autism spectrum but specific diagnoses are not mentioned and irrelevant as long you understand he’s just different, to start writing his very detailed “book” on this curious incident, to aid in his investigation of the apparent murder.

So, what we see are the events of Christopher’s (Ozzy Heath) writing, also being the play that his teacher Siobhan (Jean Childers Arnold) encourages to make of it with the help of community actors (Lisa K. Anderson, Matt Anderson, Lukas Robinson, Rex Wolfley, Kennedy Morgan and Carrie Andrews Reiberg). It does appear that Christopher’s father Ed (Eric Reiberg) and mother Judy (Afton Shepard) play themselves, but that might just be us sharing his memories. Everything will add up, though, as Christopher is exceptionally good at “maths,” as the British call them.

The first act involves the quirky pursuit of justice for Wellington, which leads to a rather upsetting discovery. In the second, resolving a new mystery means taking on the most horrific challenge of Christopher’s life – the London Underground subways.

Jay Hemphill directs this production that helps deliver Christopher’s unique perspective through image projections and the other players acting as various characters, barriers, and at several moments, choreographed chaos. The neurodivergent think in straight lines and simple facts, but the world around us is mazes and metaphors.

Lebanon high schooler Heath does an excellent job of expressing that perspective, complete with a respectfully accurate presentation of the boy’s tics and quirks. Showing this person so honestly helps us to empathize and cheer him on.

Arnold’s Siobhan is that favorite teacher we either fondly remember or wish we had. She obviously understands working with students like Christopher and making him feel respected and, in this curious context, normal. Contrast this almost too good to be true character (perhaps because seen through the boy’s eyes) with his parents, neither of whom would be named Britian’s Mom or Dad of the Year.

Reiberg and Shepard each play their roles with a brutal honesty in which they see where they slipped up, finding themselves needing and willing to do the work to restore the most important and fragile thing in Christopher’s world – trust.

This story has lots of humor and persistence and compassion in a demonstration that seeing things through a different way of thinking can lead to amazing insights. And in the end, you will cheer the answer to an A-Levels maths problem!

Christopher doesn’t mind tight spaces, so we see “The Curious Incident” in The Studio Theater at the Center for the Performing Arts in downtown Carmel, through March 29. Get tickets at civictheatre.org or thecenterpresents.org.

Teen rite of passage becomes test for all in Civic musical

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By Wendy Carson and John Belden

As you might know, the musical “The Prom” is loosely based on a true incident.* Despite historical  authenticity relative to Disney’s “Pocahontas,” this show – book by Chad Beguelin and Bob Martin, music by Matthew Sklar, from a concept by Jack Viertel – presented by Booth Tarkington Civic Theatre, directed by Michael J. Lasley, entertainingly captures the essence of the story, reflecting the attitudes found in more than just one American town.

From their perspective, at least, this is the story of two aging Broadway stars, Dee Dee Allen (Marni Lemons) and Barry Glickman (Chad Leitschuh) with vanity bigger than their talent. After scorching reviews of their latest flop, they desperately need more positive publicity. With the help of their agent, Sheldon Sapperstein (David Maxwell) and a couple of other actors in need a career boost – Angie  Dickinson (Mikayla Koharchik), who can’t seem to get out of the chorus after 20 years, and Trent Oliver (Evan Wallace), a former TV star who never loses a chance to remind you he went to Juliard – they seek to find a worthy cause that won’t strain them too much. 

Emma Nolan (Kelsey McDaniel) is a high school senior in Edgewater, Indiana, who just wants to take her girlfriend to the Prom. However, the conservative small town district’s PTA, led by Mrs. Greene (Marlana Haig), refuses to allow it, going so far as to cancel the event. Just as it seems that Emma’s ally, school principal Mr. Hawkins (Rex Wolfley), found a way to work the whole situation out, our group of “Broadway Heroes” show up and not only alienate everyone involved, but embarrass Emma.  

Luckily, Hawkins, being a devoted fan of Allen, does not run the whole gang out of town. He even takes the diva to the city’s finest restaurant, Applebee’s.  

After some legal cajoling, the PTA agrees to resume the Prom. Emma plans to take Alyssa (Kaylee Johnson-Bradley), who will finally come out to her family and everyone there. But Emma and her Broadway friends are in for a devastating surprise. 

With the support of our well-meaning heroes, Emma must find a way to take her stand, her way, so that if nothing else, she – and everyone – can dance.

Having only heard a few of the songs beforehand and knowing how the story was handled, we had some reservations as to how this would work out. Would setting the story in Indiana, reportedly as a rebuke to the former Vice President, be a mockery of Hoosiers in general? Fortunately, it’s just gentle jibes we can live with (and have that hint of truth). Rather, the musical’s creators and Lasley’s direction have woven a magical story that is the “Footloose” (with a hint of Cinderella) of our era.  

The whole cast is joyously giving their all in bringing this beautiful event to life. While I am without  enough adjectives to even begin to describe each actor’s fantastic performance, I will say that NYU graduate McDaniel’s powerful voice could land her back in the Big Apple. Broadway’s loss is our gain.

Lemons, Leitschuh, Koharchik and Wallace revel in their license to overact. Haig perfectly portrays the insidious evil of indifference and self-righteousness. Wolfley handles well being the character that is the fulcrum on which the whole plot turns.

Performances of “The Prom” run through Oct. 21 at the Tarkington theater in the Center for the Performing Arts in downtown Carmel. Feel free to bring a date, corsage optional, and arrive early as there is ongoing street construction in the area. Get info and tickets at civictheatre.org or thecenterpresents.org.

—

*The true story happened in Mississippi in 2010. (Click here for details) Thanks to Civic for sharing the link.

Entertaining ride on ‘Orient Express’

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By John Lyle Belden

There are two kinds of people who watch a production – film or stage – of the Agatha Christie mystery “Murder on the Orient Express.”

First, there are those who have never seen how it ends. If you encounter such a patron at the Booth Tarkington Civic Theatre production of the play, running through March 25, DO NOT TELL THEM WHODUNIT. Being one of the most famous and creative reveals in the genre, it’s best to be savored as it happens.

Then, there are the fans of stage, screen, or the original text, who know the answer and just enjoy the widely varied and wildly interesting cast of characters, all falling under the scrutiny of Christie’s eccentric Belgian detective, Hercule Poirot.

Penned by Ken Ludwig (at the request of the Christie estate), this “Murder on the Orient Express” more than satisfies both groups. The blizzard of clues – too many, in fact, Poirot notes – will keep newcomers guessing, and Ludwig’s comic touch ensures at least as many laughs as thrills.

Eric Reiberg is pitch-perfect as Poirot in, a credit to him and director John Michael Goodson, a fairly laid-back portrayal of the character. Rather than have an exaggerated look and personality, even his famous curled mustache is understated, letting the various suspects on board the train do the clowning. Still, his bearing, accent, and little quirks are true to character and exert the proper gravitas (in this story, the detective is already world famous).

To set up the play, we get some disturbing audio, as well as Poirot addressing the audience that what we see is a flashback to one of his most complex and troubling cases. With this, we open in Istanbul, Turkey, in 1934. Needing a quick ride across Europe, the detective travels the famed Orient Express, bound for Calais, France, as the honored guest of the director of the rail line, Monsieur Bouc (Rex Wolfley).  

Various men and women board, including a very cocky yet nervous American businessman, Samuel Ratchett (Lee Russell), who tries to hire Poirot to find out who sent him threatening letters. Offended by his rudeness, the detective refuses. But when, with the train halted by a snowdrift in what was then Yugoslavia, Ratchett lies dead of multiple stab wounds, Hercule Poirot finds himself on the case.

Aside from ever-patient conductor Michel (Ronald May) we have our suspects – in fun performances by Evangeline Bouw, Luke Faser, Lauren Frank, Susan Hill, Alexis Koshenina, Sherra Lasley, and Clay Mabbitt – who all have alibis. And what might the motive be? As Poirot peels back the layers of the mystery and discovers hidden identities, he can only come to one conclusion. Or, perhaps, two.

A script like this allows for going a little over the top, and Lasley is a hoot as our brash American who married into riches and belts into song. Bouw is sweetly memorable as a countess who happened to go to medical school. Hill is commanding as the Russian princess; Koshenina is retreating as a shy missionary. Mabbitt and Frank slyly arouse our suspicions even before their characters board – but we actually see where they are at the apparent time of the murder.

I’ll say no more. You need to see this for yourself, but tickets for this wild ride are selling fast.

The Orient Express was an actual rail line, but, alas, its last departure was in 2009. Next best thing is to see this version. Performances are in the appropriately intimate confines of The Studio Theater at the Center for the Performing Arts in downtown Carmel. For information and tickets, go to civictheatre.org or thecenterpresents.org.