Family battle reflects historic tiff

By John Lyle Belden

The first thing to understand about “My Mother and the Michigan/Ohio War,” a new comedy by Paul Stroili presented by Epilogue Players, is that there actually was a war, if you could call it that.

In 1835-36, Michigan’s applying for statehood brought to a head a long-simmering conflict over its southern border – not with Indiana (that was set), but with neighboring Ohio, as the disputed “Toledo Strip” included the port city, its river (and potential canal), and lots of fertile land. Originally caused by badly-drawn maps of the Great Lakes, by this point the stakes were much higher, bringing out thousands in militias on both sides. The resulting compromise with Congress kept the border where it is today (with Toledo in Ohio) and in exchange gained Michigan the full Upper Peninsula – thus the nearly-forgotten affair affected the borders of three U.S. states (sorry, Wisconsin!). Also, nobody died.

In recent years, no one cared more about this history than committed Michigander Freddie Campbell, living in a town near the Ohio line with lifelong dreams of (1) a son playing football for the Michigan Wolverines and (2) a historical reenactment of the Michigan-Ohio War at the town festival. The first goal changed as his child with Izzy (Barb Weaver) was a girl, Carey (Jeanna Little), who at least went to UM in marching band, and their adopted son, Josh (Oscar Otero-Ortiz) was given a full-ride scholarship at arch-rival Ohio State. Freddie fell short on the second, dying of a heart attack while working on elements of the reenactment.

Months after the funeral, as Izzy moves out of the family home, she hopes them all seeing the memorabilia and history in Freddie’s collections will help her persuade her adult kids to fulfill their father’s dream at the upcoming summer’s festival. While Carey and Josh have fully blended their sibling and college rivalries, there is one thing they agree on – no border war play! Aside from general reluctance, they know the mind-numbingly intense detail to which their father had gone.

I’ve related so much here, and that’s merely the setup for a wonderful story of family conflict that – like the historic skirmish it relates to – is largely bloodless while important to its participants. This is Izzy’s story, as she not only relates it to us in the audience but also steps across the fourth wall a time or two for our help. Weaver plays her as one with wisdom from hearing about old political strategies and watching all the Wolverine-Buckeye games, slyly employing it here.

The fact that the “kids” don’t act completely grown up around their mother helps. Little plays Carey as ambitious, eager to look forward and leave old obsessions behind, though unresolved issues are starting to show in her drinking (which Mom has noticed). Otero-Ortiz has Josh retain his boyish charm while at ease with his obsessive-compulsive neurodivergency.

Their competitive nature comes into play when Izzy brings out “Boarder War” – a historically detailed board game Freddy designed, based on the 1835 events. Thanks to director Catherine Mobley, their rounds of game play are more interesting than you’d think, adding to the tension brought on by family memories, keepsakes, and hidden showtunes.

Hilarious at times, heartfelt always, this play brings out how what seems like minor issues can feel like major battles, and in the right spirit we can find a way to draw a line that works for everyone.

Mobley was assisted by Jenny Braun, with Amanda Lane as stage manager. The set design and decoration by Andrew Burnett, Melody Burnett, Catherine and Ed Mobley, and Susan Yeaw would make any Wolverine fan feel at home.

“My Mother and the Michigan/Ohio War” has performances Thursday through Sunday, Nov. 19-22, at 1849 N. Alabama St. (corner of 19th and Alabama), Indianapolis. For info and tickets, see epilogueplayers.com.

Family drama simmers in ‘Sancocho’

By John Lyle Belden

Food – like language and music – is an essential part of culture, and peoples all over the world have their signature dishes. In Latin America, that includes sancocho (from the Spanish verb for parboil), a rich stew made with various meats, vegetables and tubers. For Puerto Ricans, both on the island and in New York City, every family has a recipe passed down through generations. According to the Edible Manhattan website, sancocho “is a staple of family gatherings and celebrations, a meal designed as much for sharing as for sustenance.”

In “Sancocho: A Culinary & Culturally Immersive Play” by Christian Eve Cato, presented by Cultura Live Indy at The District Theatre, two sisters prepare the stew, but the truly spicy “dish” is their conversation.

Caridad (Alicia Sims), the older sister, prepares the dish as she was taught by their mother. Renata (Yolanda Valdivia), who is 25 years younger, was encouraged instead to study and is now an attorney, lamenting her lack of kitchen skills. There are other visible differences between them. Caridad has darker skin and her children are grown, while fair-skinned Renata is very pregnant with her first child (a daughter). Their mother has passed and their father – who each remembers differently – is dying.

Renata wants to discuss the details of their father’s will; Caridad wants her to cut up the yams.

While the stew simmers, the conversation often comes to a boil as past resentments surface, as well as experiences remembered differently, and finally some serious family secrets. As it often is with siblings, nothing boils over as humor and attempts at understanding are sprinkled in. The secret ingredient of sancocho, after all, is love.

And I don’t just mean “simmers” metaphorically or stage-pretending. A Dutch oven style vessel sets on a heated surface onstage in the intimate District cabaret. Stage crew start the broth prior to the show, and ingredients are added throughout the play, bringing aroma and authenticity to the scene. Afterward, as well as an opportunity to meet the playwright, there will be samples of sancocho served by Cultura Live Indy in the lobby.

Directed by Andres Lopez, we get wonderfully raw performances of a relationship that’s been more tested than either care to admit. Their different perspectives are painfully obvious at the beginning and must be reconciled before they can share the meal. Valdivia presents Renata as a Millennial feeling detached from her roots, consumed by the business of the present. Sims (“The UnCuT Diamond”) as Caridad feels the weight of the past, especially now. The process of cooking for her is not just a chore, it is a necessary catalyst for what is happening now, and about to happen.

Lopez said he had reached out to Cato before taking on this project, ensuring he would be the right person to “shepherd” (his word) the play – his roots being in Mexico rather than Puerto Rico. Dramaturg Taylor Harmon, an IU graduate living in Boston, applied her studies in Latinx culture to help with the show’s recipe. Other important ingredients include stage manager Rick Northam, production manager Kelly Kel, and tech director Jess Knutson.

A delicious and satisfying experience all around, gather for “Sancocho” Friday through Sunday, Nov. 13-15, at 627 Massachusetts Ave., downtown Indianapolis. Get tickets at indydistricttheatre.org.

IRT: Laughs and love with immigrant family in ‘Kim’s Convenience’

By John Lyle Belden

If the title “Kim’s Convenience” sounds familiar, the play by Ins Choi now presented by Indiana Repertory Theatre is the hit show that inspired the Canadian television sitcom of the same name. If it doesn’t, well, you are still in for a treat.

The action centers on an independent convenience store in the Regent Park neighborhood of Toronto, owned and run by Korean immigrant Mr. Kim (Tony K. Nam), known familiarly as Appa. His wife is known as Umma (Tuyèt Thi Pham). Their daughter Janet (Jenny S. Lee) is 30, single, and a photographer with occasional clients. Their 32-year-old son Jung (Jae Woo), they don’t talk about.

Austin Michael Young plays all other roles including customers; Mr. Lee (“the Black man with the Asian name”), who arrives with a tempting offer; and Alex, a local police officer who knew Jung and Janet in high school.

After more than three decades in North America, Appa still has issues with English and making himself understood. This naturally leads to much of the comedy, scripted by Choi from his experience as a Korean-Canadian to sound natural, the way hilarious linguistic confusion happens in real life. Add in Appa’s eccentricities, such as his use of Korean martial arts and his obsession with Korean history (feeding a hatred of Japan), and I have rarely laughed so hard at a show as I have with this.

The comic moments blend seamlessly with some deep family drama. “This store is my story,” Appa says, as he seriously considers its next chapter. His options are basically taking Mr. Lee’s generous payout and retiring, which he doesn’t feel good about, or giving Kim’s Convenience to Janet, who does not want it. Meanwhile, Umma makes contact with her estranged son, who is unhappy with his current life despite recently becoming a father himself.

Appa’s attempts to get Janet more involved with the store intensify both the comic and dramatic atmosphere, with aspects of racial and social profiling in his game of “Steal or No Steal.”

A helpful note: When Appa and Umma speak to each other in Korean, the English translations are projected on the backstage wall.

Direction is by associate artistic director cara hinh, who considers herself “such a Janet.” Scenic design – a perfectly organized and stocked c-store floor and counter – is by Yoon Bae.

Performances have a sense of familiarity among the cast, making their interactions – whether sentimental or tense – sparkle. Nam is relatable as a concerned father, while expressing himself in Appa’s unique way. Pham keeps Umma focused on practical matters, anchored by love and faith. Lee’s Janet is a free spirit, while respectful of her family and culture. Young gives Alex a sense of nervous adventure, hoping to connect with an old friend, but finding connection with his sister. Woo presents Joo as burdened by regret that is aggravated by pride.

Learn the Korean name for ginseng, what happened in 1904, and enjoy the heartwarming experience of “Kim’s Convenience,” through Nov. 15 on the intimate Janet Allen stage at the IRT, 140 W. Washington in the heart of downtown Indianapolis. Get info and tickets at irtlive.com.

Epsilon presents famous ‘Family’

By John Lyle Belden

Epsilon Theatrical Company works its unique magic on what is becoming a musical classic, “The Addams Family: A New Musical Comedy.” A Broadway hit with book by Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice, music and lyrics by Andrew Lippa, based on the popular characters by Charles Addams, this “mysterious spooky kooky ooky” clan is well suited to the family atmosphere of ETC.

Director and choreographer Buddy Reeder, a native Hoosier who has performed and directed shows nationwide, embraced the vibe of both the company and the show. Performances are upbeat and energetic, employing the stage, the back of the audience, and the aisleways in between.

Reeder said that after casting special actor Sarah Gasper, a devoted fan who has attended more than 125 performances of the musical and appeared in a number of community productions, he was inspired to greatly expand the number of “Ancestors” who haunt the Addams estate. Their near-constant presence – as chorus, in dance numbers, and roaming the audience – help us all feel like part of the show. We also get, during scene and costume changes, some moments of corny humor with a couple of Cave-Addamses played by Jack London and his grandmother Laurie London.

The family members practically stepped out of the old New Yorker cartoons: gregarious patriarch Gomez (Kent Livingston), sultry slender Morticia (Katie van den Heuvel), darkly darling daughter Wednesday (Gemma Rollison), glutton for punishment son Pugsley (Judah Livingston), charmingly eccentric Uncle Fester (Rodney Sciba), feisty Grandma (Tammy Coss), shaggy Cousin Itt (Ezzy Livingston), and butler/looming presence Lurch (Sean Stroup), who ensures that Thing (uncredited) is always on hand.

The plot (similar to the old oddball family comedy “You Can’t Take It With You”) involves the possibility that nearly-adult Wednesday has somehow fallen in love – and with a “normal” boy! Lucas Beineke (Chase Cornelius) is so okay with the weirdness that they are secretly engaged. Their intentions are to be announced at an Addams family dinner with his parents, Mal and Alice (Jim O’Connor and Brianne Snow) of Ohio, as guests. To ensure mayhem, they will play a very Addams party game.

Meanwhile, Gomez and Morticia’s relationship will be tested by Wednesday’s insistence that her mother not know about the engagement (which Pugsley will privately seek to wreck).

We will also find out Fester’s infatuation with a certain heavenly body – which is presented in a nice special effect.

Other Ancestors are played by Norah Amrose, London Bramer, Fender Brokamp, Lydia Capps, Alec Cole, Sophia Dam, Andy DeLoughery, Sophie Eastman, Mark Gasper, Klara Hollaway, Robin Kim, Thomas Kim, Eliott King, Amelia Landrum, Sharon Livingston, Gavin McMillin, Christian Parchman, Breanne Penrod, Lacey Pierce, Maranatha Potter, Brooklynn Shaw, Rain Stafford, Bella Velasco, Olivia Venable, and Luke Wilson, who is also a featured guitarist.

Rollison is exceptional in her central role, which says a lot considering the talent she shares the stage with. Cornelius as Lucas is endearing with gentle bravery. Sciba gives Fester boyish charm and joyous animated demeanor. Livingston gives Gomez his famous combination of wit and being at wit’s end, while van den Heuvel makes Morticia’s demeanor both chilling and seductive. O’Connor delivers the anticipated amount of bluster as Mr. Beineke, while Snow gives us one of the show’s hilarious highlights as Alice.

A not-so-scary spooky treat for your October, “The Addams Family” has performances Friday and Saturday evening, Saturday and Sunday afternoon (Oct. 23-25), at Broadway United Methodist Church, 609 E. 29th St., Indianapolis. Get tickets and info at epsilontheatricalco.org.

Southbank delivers brilliant Bechdel biography

By John Lyle Belden

Southbank Theatre Company opens its season of Origins with the coming of age and coming-out musical, “Fun Home,” based on the graphic memoir by Alison Bechdel, with book and lyrics by Lisa Kron and music by Jeanine Tesori.

Cartoonist Bechdel, reaching the age that her father died, tries to come to terms with the past with her art. As she draws, stumped for the right captions to add, she remembers her life as a restless girl with her brother, sister, and parents in a “House on Maple Avenue” in Beech Creek, Pa., as well as her fateful first year of college when, in her words, she came out as a lesbian, and her closeted gay father killed himself.

We find her upbringing to be a little unusual, in a house with a museum-like collection of various antiques, with a father who not only teaches English at the high school but also runs a mortuary (the “Fun[eral] Home” of the title) passed down through the family. Father always has need of a young handyman to help with home improvement projects – his true purpose to which the kids are oblivious, while their mother understands too well.

Directed by Southbank founder and artistic director Marcia Eppich-Harris, she has again assembled an excellent cast. Patrick Vaughn plays conflicted and complex father Bruce, exacting and demanding with others as he strives to maintain tight control on himself. Afton Shephard gives an intense portrayal of self-sacrificing mother Helen. Orion Cortez and Lilly Adams give appropriately goofy teen performances as siblings John and Christian. Their comfort with unconventional surroundings especially comes through in the “Come to the Fun Home” TV-commercial skit they work on with little sister Alison – darkly “fun” in the conventional sense of the word.

Alison herself is portrayed by three actors:

Julie Lyn Barber is splendid as Adult Alison, greeting the memories playing out before her with a grin of hard-won wisdom and an unshakable sense of regret. Sharing her lack of certainty ironically makes her a more reliable narrator.

Emery Haley is Medium Alison, the college freshman discovering herself while struggling to understand her father – unaware their last day together will be their last day ever. Her coming out – first to herself, then her family – is a relatable experience for many, and we can all sense her apprehension at life away from home for the first time. We share her joy as she declares she’s “Changing My Major” to making love to Joan – smartly played by Nia Hughes. Her growing anxiety over life’s changes is also palpable.

Ellie Richart has a big role as Small Allison. This is not the kind of show that says “that’s me as a kid” and moves on – many of the pieces of this play’s puzzle are revealed in her early life. Richart’s talent especially shines in “Ring of Keys” in which the subject of the song is never seen but must be realized through the girl’s description and expression; this is a pivotal moment in Alison’s young life, and Richart nails it.

Bobby Haley also does very well as the various men in Bruce’s life. Most scenes of them together come off more serene than tawdry, adding to the growing tension as the Bechdels find their life of secrets ever harder to manage.  

Music director is Kristin Cutler, choreography by Andre Williams, and stage manager is Madison Pickering. The set design by Scott Hall features large reproductions of panels from the book made by Eppich-Harris and Casey Ross.

A compelling production of the Tony-winning, Pulitzer-nominated masterpiece, “Fun Home” has four remaining performances, Thursday through Sunday, Sept. 24-27 at Shelton Auditorium, 1000 W. 42nd St., Indianapolis (southwest corner of Butler University campus). Get info and tickets at southbanktheatre.org.

At Center Stage, mature folks don’t always act that way

By John Lyle Belden

Things don’t feel as perfect when you are past sixty.

“Morning’s at Seven,” the title of a popular comedy by Indiana-born writer Paul Osborn, is a line from the Robert Browning poem that famously says, “God’s in his heaven – all’s right with the world,” reflecting a moment of perfection.

Presented by Center Stage Community Theatre of Lebanon, directed by Jan Jamison, the play presents the story of four sisters of a certain age still living in the same neighborhood (three of them sharing a back yard) in the 1920s.

In the home on stage left (audience right), Cora (Cathie Morgan) lives with husband Thor Swanson (Sydney S. Loomis) and never-married sister Arry Gibbs (Elizabeth Young-Collins), who was invited to stay with them 40 years ago, and circumstances just never changed.

On the other side of the stage is the home of Ida Bolton (Beth Popplewell), husband Carl (Scott Stockton) and son Homer (Ryan Moskalick). Up the street somewhere backstage is the home of oldest sister Esther (Molly Kraus) and her husband David Crampton (Rick Sharp), a retired college professor with a very low opinion of his wife’s family.

The opening scene conversations show these folks making a lot out of what little goes on in their lives, setting a tone of gentle eccentricity. This gets even odder with the arrival of Homer with his girlfriend of the last 12 years (the last five engaged), Myrtle Brown (Amy Keitt). He is 40, she 39, and there is even a house in town prepared for them, yet there seems to be no hurry for marriage and Homer moving out of his old room.

This atmosphere of general silliness contains some very serious issues. Esther makes a surprise visit in defiance of her controlling husband’s insistence she never see them. Meanwhile Carl has severe depressive “spells” in which he questions his whole life’s purpose. David arrives and haughtily declares his wife can no longer live on the main floor of their house. But with his background in philosophy, David takes interest in Carl’s laments and starts to mentor him – while exploiting his home-improvement skills to make his “crystal fortress” into a duplex.

As this goes on, Thor finds himself caught between Cora’s desire to have a future only with him and Arry’s fear of growing older alone. This hints at a deeper secret, which the other sisters feel they have figured out.

By the next morning, we wonder, will all be right with their world again?

This juxtaposition of issues that feel modern with the quaint atmosphere of early 20th century Americana makes for a narrative both charming and intriguing. Jamison relished the opportunity to give seven of the nine roles to older actors, who show themselves quite lively and capable of the ironic immaturity called for in a good comedy. Each presents their long-set quirks in entertaining fashion, even the “younger” roles. Moskalick’s Homer is practically a caricature of a “mama’s boy” (we’d see him as a bit on the spectrum nowadays), while Keitt’s Myrtle maintains impeccable manners and finishing-school charm while working to bring about her long-deferred nuptials. Throughout we see that age doesn’t alleviate fears, just reshapes them.

Performances of “Morning’s at Seven” are the evenings of Fridays and Saturdays, afternoons of Sundays, through Oct. 4 at 604 Powell St. in Lebanon. Get info and tickets at centerstagecommunitytheatre.com.

‘Extreme’ measures test family in need

By John Lyle Belden

In the wake of tragedy, we often have the wish that we could start over, have a new life, even a new house. For a select few, at least the latter happened, aired on national television. A desperate Texas family seeks to join that number in the drama, “Extreme Home Makeover,” by Makasha Copeland, presented by American Lives Theatre at the Phoenix Theatre Cultural Centre.

The title references the ABC television show, “Extreme Makeover: Home Edition” (using its common nickname to avoid trademark issues). The process of being chosen, among hundreds of applicants, involved making a video recording to audition by showing both the necessary home renovations and the worthiness of the homeowning family. Scenes here are frequently played to an unseen camera, putting the audience in the position of the mysterious producers who could decide the family’s fate.

Three generations are crowded into this Kingsville, Texas, home: Valentina (Sofia Salgada), her mother Guadalupe (Caroline Lee Sanchez), teen son Marco (Diego Sanchez-Galvan), and 10-year-old daughter Lupe (Laila Matuk). Valentina’s husband, David, recently died, leaving her struggling to keep the house and unable to afford its upkeep, including a broken toilet.

Guadalupe is not thrilled at all about this bid for televised fame. She sees it as yet another insult to the honor of a family who lived on the land since it was part of Mexico two centuries ago, since then being made to work it for the benefit of non-Latino owners. Valentina, however, is practically blinded by hope, insisting on getting the audition just right so that a new home can help rectify their tenuous situation. The children, eager to please both Mom and Abuela, try hard to do their part in the scheme. Marco applies for his first job, while Lupe – who talks to “Aybeecee” like a friend she’s trying to impress – seeks to prove she’s not as useless as she feels.

Local actor Carlos Medina Maldonado directs. He saw the play in development while a student at Texas Tech, noting it reminded him of his own family, with aspects we can all relate to. Intertwined with the themes of hard times and holding on to one’s culture is the universal experience of grief, made more intense when it is the family patriarch who is suddenly gone. Aside from some clothes and possessions, their principal reminder of David is a video of him at Lupe’s last birthday – his singing to her embarrassing then, but treasured now.

The cast’s familial chemistry, combining personalities that are distinct and natural, draw us into their world, feeling both their loving bonds and growing need. Even when they clash, each acts from their perspective of love. Salgada’s Valentina is driven, barely hiding her growing desperation while feeling it is up to her to make everything right. Sanchez’s Guadelupe is a bit of a curmudgeon but adopts a softer touch to help mend their growing crisis, coming through as only a loving grandma can. Sanchez-Galvan’s Marco feels the weight of man-of-the-house expectations, though he’s not feeling quite ready to grow up yet. Matuk, who is over twice the age of the girl she plays, maintains Lupe’s sweetness and innocence, along with a naïve grit of one who doesn’t know what she allegedly can’t do – showing that where there’s a will, there’s Google.

The stage, brilliantly designed and built by Carlos Teeters, has no visible walls and audience seating on two sides, showing the fishbowl environment brought about by private spaces being exposed to judging strangers. We see the floor plan, while the people upon it show what makes a house a home.

Note the dialogue is a Spanglish mixture that would be genuinely heard in a home like this, yet not too hard to follow for non-Spanish speakers.

An emotionally engaging and inspiring story of a family needing to make some changes, “Extreme Home Makeover” runs through Aug. 2 in the Basile black-box stage at 705 N. Illinois St., downtown Indianapolis. Get tickets at phoenixtheatre.org, and information at americanlivestheatre.org.

Epilogue: A story of loss, discovery, and healing

By Wendy Carson

Joy is a fairly typical New Yorker. She is a designer who works from home and is still single at 36. What makes her special is that she just received a heart transplant. Like many recipients, she wants to know more about the man who literally gave her his heart, so she writes a note to the donor’s family thanking them for their generosity and giving her details in case they too wish to meet with her.

This is the dramedy “The Tin Woman,” by Sean Grennan, presented by Epilogue Players, directed by Nicole Amsler.

Joy (Laura Gellin) finds that as her body quickly heals, her mind and soul still have issues. Meanwhile, family members of the donor, Jack, deal with their loss each in their own way. His mother, Alice (Tanya Haas) and sister Sammy (Lauren Janning), each feel meeting the recipient might bring some sense of closure to them as a family. However, his father, Hank (Eric Bryant), being true to his generation and upbringing, has no desire to deal with the loss at all.

Add in Joy’s overly perky nurse (Sarah Froehlke) and goofy but supportive best friend Darla, (Mary DeBoer) – as well as an almost forgotten chance encounter – and you have the makings for a bittersweet tale of love, loss, and second chances.

Since Jack (Matt McKee) is ever present in everyone’s minds throughout the whole story, the play has that character present in every scene, observing and occasionally interacting with characters. Still, he is merely a “presence” in the story, not some sort of ghostly specter. This conceit made for a more powerful story and further helped to illustrate the importance of organ and tissue donation in our world. He also gets to speak in flashback scenes.

I was also impressed with Amsler’s decision to cast two different actresses for each of the minor roles (Nurse/Darla) as opposed to having the same person play both. This allows for each performer to fully inhabit the character and each gave an outstanding turn in their own right.

I must say that the acting in this show is so spot on, the delicacy of each performance could easily be overlooked. We all know someone who is the embodiment of Hank, Sammy, and Alice, and each actor portrays them perfectly. Haas presents the mother who must be a pillar of strength, despite the cracks. Janning’s Sammy is a young woman who didn’t have to completely grow up, with a job as a pre-K teacher and openly idealistic and emotional at her parents’ home. Bryant plays Hank bitter, cynical, and self-medicating, but even when angry, never abusive.  

Few of us personally know someone in Joy’s situation but could imagine ourselves in her shoes. I feel Gellin did an amazing job of bringing her to life. She embodies what Joy refers to as an “interesting sense of humor,” using it to mask the feelings she must reckon with.

However, I feel that Jack’s character is really the key performance, with McKee sheer perfection in his approach. He manages to show his feelings so subtly with just a change of expression or shift of his eyes and while his mannerisms speak volumes, he never detracts from the story unfolding onstage, just accentuates it.

This show is a wonderful peek into the ins and outs of the donation process and a must-see for anyone on the fence about whether or not this is a viable option for themselves.

Performances of “The Tin Woman” are Thursday through Sunday, April 23-26, at 1849 N. Alabama St. (corner of 19th and Alabama), Indianapolis. Get info and tickets at epilogueplayers.com.

IndyFringe: Horse Girl

This was part of the 20th Anniversary Indy Fringe Theatre Festival in August 2025. Review originally posted on our Facebook page.

By Wendy Carson

Jason Adams once again brings us a spectacularly delightful offering to the Fringe with, “Horse Girl.” It’s an imaginative look at the history of his birth parents by the man who only knew the barest of details about them.

His father was a blacksmith from Liverpool, and his mother was an equestrian rider.

The show focuses mainly on his mother, Matilda (Tilde) McCullough, the descendant of a storied horse family. Details given include the Birth of Dressage and the History of the Fur Trade in Southern Ontario. We are also introduced to the magical horse, Ulysses, who would be her partner in the competitions that cemented her legacy in the horse world .

A small hint of his father’s backstory shows him turning away from the family business of fishing to become a blacksmith who would one day repair a show for Ulysses, thus introducing him to Tilde.

Their brief affair would end with the conception of Jason but due to family pressures, he would ultimately be given up for adoption and come into the care of his true mother, Janet Adams.

This bittersweet tale is told with all the whimsy and charm we have come to expect from Adams. For those of you not familiar with his style, think Winnie the Pooh meets Monty Python.

This show is appropriate for all ages, in fact, some younger audience members will likely be asked to assist with some of the effects.

Adams has grown so much as a storyteller through the years and this show has him at the pinnacle of his talents.

Hyperion presents man’s ‘zero hour’

By John Lyle Belden

BE ADVISED: This play explores heavy topics, including suicide.

What does the dark, serious comedy “Rocket Man” by Steven Dietz, performed for one weekend by Hyperion Players in Fishers, directed by Daniel Maloy, have to do with the 1972 hit song by Elton John and Bernie Taupin?

In my mind, absolutely nothing – and everything.

The song was reportedly inspired by a sci-fi story by Ray Bradbury about a time when being an astronaut will be just a regular job. The lyrics are less about the wonder of traveling in space and more about the ennui and loneliness of the very long commute.

In this play, Donny (Bailey Hunt), in his 40s, finds himself in a crisis he can’t just brush off as “midlife.” It’s a crisis of time and space. He’s “losing” time; hours and days seem to pass without his noticing. He plans a milestone birthday party for teenage daughter Trisha (Amelia Bostick), not realizing it was a week ago.

As for space, he’s been changing his relationship to it. Having quit his long-time successful job as a land surveyor and abandoned his past ambition to be a landscape architect, Donny cleared his house of all its objects – to the shock of Trisha, surprise of good friend and neighbor Buck (Greg Fiebig), and chagrin of his ex-wife Rita (Isabel Hunt) – except for the attic, in which he has reopened the skylight and set up his E-Z Boy recliner for stargazing.

Donny’s best friend and former survey partner Louise (Lauren Taylor) comes over as well. Her chronic insomnia has somehow led her to study at a seminary. Buck confides in her on a spiritual manner: he is sure he is hearing voices around his own house, telling him to build an ark (like in the biblical Noah story).

Rita contends with the consequences of her “year of being real,” in which she always told people what she thought of them – a factor in her and Donny’s divorce. Still, it is his unsettled mind that primarily drives him.

There is also a crosswalk sign, “terrible” cookies, the moon and stars, an umbrella, things not done, things not finished, the song, “Quiet Nights of Quiet Stars,” and some recognizable signs that a person is taking a one-way voyage.

However, once we reach that other world – where things are the same, yet different – the troubled feelings aren’t necessarily better.

This inventive look at loss and what-ifs is wonderfully presented and incredibly challenging. Hunt’s performance is of a man feeling the pressure of being between worlds – age, creativity, even literal planets – who only feels relief in a desperate plan. The others play well their unusual aspects, enriching the context for the story’s Bradbury-esque strangeness.

Fiebig also designed the excellent attic setting in which nearly all the action takes place.

This play has remaining performances tonight (as I post this) and Sunday, May 31-June 1, at The Switch theatre in Ji-Eun Lee Music Academy, 10029 126th St., Fishers. Info and tickets at hyperionplayers.com.

– – –

Can’t help but see the events of the pivotal moment between Acts in these lyrics:

“And I think it’s gonna be a long, long time
‘Til touchdown brings me ’round again to find
I’m not the man they think I am at home
Oh, no, no, no
I’m a rocket man
Rocket man
Burning out his fuse up here alone.”