Family battle reflects historic tiff

By John Lyle Belden

The first thing to understand about “My Mother and the Michigan/Ohio War,” a new comedy by Paul Stroili presented by Epilogue Players, is that there actually was a war, if you could call it that.

In 1835-36, Michigan’s applying for statehood brought to a head a long-simmering conflict over its southern border – not with Indiana (that was set), but with neighboring Ohio, as the disputed “Toledo Strip” included the port city, its river (and potential canal), and lots of fertile land. Originally caused by badly-drawn maps of the Great Lakes, by this point the stakes were much higher, bringing out thousands in militias on both sides. The resulting compromise with Congress kept the border where it is today (with Toledo in Ohio) and in exchange gained Michigan the full Upper Peninsula – thus the nearly-forgotten affair affected the borders of three U.S. states (sorry, Wisconsin!). Also, nobody died.

In recent years, no one cared more about this history than committed Michigander Freddie Campbell, living in a town near the Ohio line with lifelong dreams of (1) a son playing football for the Michigan Wolverines and (2) a historical reenactment of the Michigan-Ohio War at the town festival. The first goal changed as his child with Izzy (Barb Weaver) was a girl, Carey (Jeanna Little), who at least went to UM in marching band, and their adopted son, Josh (Oscar Otero-Ortiz) was given a full-ride scholarship at arch-rival Ohio State. Freddie fell short on the second, dying of a heart attack while working on elements of the reenactment.

Months after the funeral, as Izzy moves out of the family home, she hopes them all seeing the memorabilia and history in Freddie’s collections will help her persuade her adult kids to fulfill their father’s dream at the upcoming summer’s festival. While Carey and Josh have fully blended their sibling and college rivalries, there is one thing they agree on – no border war play! Aside from general reluctance, they know the mind-numbingly intense detail to which their father had gone.

I’ve related so much here, and that’s merely the setup for a wonderful story of family conflict that – like the historic skirmish it relates to – is largely bloodless while important to its participants. This is Izzy’s story, as she not only relates it to us in the audience but also steps across the fourth wall a time or two for our help. Weaver plays her as one with wisdom from hearing about old political strategies and watching all the Wolverine-Buckeye games, slyly employing it here.

The fact that the “kids” don’t act completely grown up around their mother helps. Little plays Carey as ambitious, eager to look forward and leave old obsessions behind, though unresolved issues are starting to show in her drinking (which Mom has noticed). Otero-Ortiz has Josh retain his boyish charm while at ease with his obsessive-compulsive neurodivergency.

Their competitive nature comes into play when Izzy brings out “Boarder War” – a historically detailed board game Freddy designed, based on the 1835 events. Thanks to director Catherine Mobley, their rounds of game play are more interesting than you’d think, adding to the tension brought on by family memories, keepsakes, and hidden showtunes.

Hilarious at times, heartfelt always, this play brings out how what seems like minor issues can feel like major battles, and in the right spirit we can find a way to draw a line that works for everyone.

Mobley was assisted by Jenny Braun, with Amanda Lane as stage manager. The set design and decoration by Andrew Burnett, Melody Burnett, Catherine and Ed Mobley, and Susan Yeaw would make any Wolverine fan feel at home.

“My Mother and the Michigan/Ohio War” has performances Thursday through Sunday, Nov. 19-22, at 1849 N. Alabama St. (corner of 19th and Alabama), Indianapolis. For info and tickets, see epilogueplayers.com.

Neighbors take offense while building a fence in CCP comedy

By John Lyle Belden

It’s said that “good fences make good neighbors,” but that depends on where the fence is.

At least that’s the case with “Native Gardens,” the comedy by Karen Zacarias presented by Carmel Community Players at The Cat, directed by Lori Raffel. Set nowadays in a nice Washington D.C. neighborhood, near-retired couple Frank and Virginia Butley welcome young couple Pablo and Tania Del Valle, who buy the home next door.

Frank (Larry Adams), who worked for the General Services Administration and does consulting from home, takes pride in the yard and flowerbed he has crafted with great care for years, hoping to finally rise above Second Place in the local gardening competition.

Virginia (Vickie Cornelius Phipps) is a strong-willed woman from a Polish-American family, now a top engineer with a major defense contractor. She doesn’t hesitate to speak her mind.

Pablo (Oscar Otero Ortiz), who was disowned by his wealthy family in Chile for marrying a poor “United Statsian,” worked his way through law school and has been accepted to a major D.C. firm. He hopes to make partner.

Tania (Yolanda Valdivia), from New Mexico – her family was there when it was just “Mexico” – is about to complete her doctorate in Social Work as well as her obvious pregnancy. Her plans for the Del Valles’ back yard are a bit different from what’s on Frank’s side: keep the big oak tree, no pesticides, and all plants native to the area.

One thing both couples can agree on is that the chain-link fence between them must go!

Replacing this barrier with a nice wooden fence must happen quickly, as Pablo impulsively invited his fellow attorneys – including a named senior partner – to his backyard for a barbecue the next weekend. However, when work begins, a routine property survey leads to a bizarre “border war.” How neighborly!

What could start out as a bit of a fish-out-of-water situation soon becomes a meditation on precisely whose “water” this is. Being near the nation’s Capital, there are political overtones – the Butleys are right-of-center, more Bush-era Republicans than the current strain; while the Del Valles are more left-of-center (New Mexico is demographically Democratic) and Tania considers herself Latinx. This informs their actions regarding what each one feels entitled to, as they work within their differing paradigms to be good people.

Our four actors deliver great examples of being bitter without becoming unlikable, as each flashes from friendly to comically enraged at a moment’s notice. As words are said (including a swear in Spanish), acorns are thrown, and legal action threatened, there seems to be little actual malice.

Katherine Floyd, Jacob Slager, and stage manager Susan Yeaw work efficiently as “Mr. Mow It All” yard services, doing the fence removal, survey, contract work and scene changes.

Kudos to Joyce Pendleton for her set decoration of the beautiful flower gardens and realistic tree.

“Native Gardens” is like a fun sitcom with lots of subtext about differing views of land and our relationships to it and each other. It points not to a position of right or wrong, but rather – however we individually see things – to being good neighbors.

Performances run through Aug. 16 at The Cat, 254 Veterans Way in the heart of downtown Carmel. See carmelplayers.org or thecat.biz.