By John Lyle Belden
With “The Secret Garden: The Musical,” Main Street Productions brings to life the popular English children’s story (first published in the U.S.) by Frances Hodgson Burnett, adapted with book and lyrics by Marsha Norman, and music by Lucy Simon, a Tony-winning Broadway hit in 1991.
The current Westfield production, directed by Andrea Odle, reflects life in the early years of the 20th century when death seemed far more common. In fact, most of the cast are ghosts.
Mary Lennox (Polly Hamm), a spoiled 10-ish year-old girl living in India (then under British rule) finds herself the bizarre beneficiary of her military elite parents’ neglect. A cholera outbreak kills all the adults including Mary’s father Albert (Josh Vander Missen), mother Rose (Heather Hansen), and servant Ayah (Elizabeth Belle), but sparing her. Discovered by British authorities, Mary is sent to England and an uncle she has never met. Guardians unseen but sometimes heard and felt, the spirits follow.
The manor at Misselthwaite on the misty Yorkshire Moors is already understood to be haunted, most recently by the ghost of Mary’s mother’s sister Lily (Kata Ewigleben), who passed 10 years before, as well by as her surviving husband, reclusive hunchback Arichibald Craven (Mike Lipphardt). He is attended by servants, headed by Mrs. Medlock (Mary Garner), and his physician brother Neville Craven (Braden Hunt).
Of course, the arrival of an energetic and naturally curious girl will bring about some changes. Mary develops a friendship with Martha the chambermaid (Tessa Gibbons) and her outdoorsy brother Dickon (Nate Moore), as well gardener Ben Weatherstaff (Ron Freeman), and eventually Mary’s cousin Colin (Harper Moore), who, though “sickly,” is at least as impetuous as her.
Other members of the ghostly chorus are played by Brynn Lee, Amanda McCabe, Bryan Gallet, Jackson Stollings, Connor Phelan, Ryley Trottier, Darrin Gowan and Ellen Vander Missen.
The titular Garden is “secret” in that as it is a reminder of Lily (who had tended it), Archibald has ordered it locked and abandoned, with the key hidden and the door obscured by ivy. These obstacles prove no match for our spirited, and spirit-aided, heroine.
The stage musical leans into the mystical and magical aspects of Burnett’s story. While it feels supernatural to the characters, the results are more the result of persistence and working towards healing, both mentally and physically. Inspiring and holding our interest as a spell of sorts is woven, the “magic” is something attainable to us all. (And nothing says you can’t talk to a robin when you need to.)
Hamm is naturally charming as Mary. Even when obstinate with the upheaval of her life at the beginning, she is still a likable girl. This makes it all the more wild when she goes over-the-top in her loud refusal to be sent away to school – a humorous highlight of the show. Moore as Colin effectively mixes bratty outbursts with frustration at his bedridden life, conditions that improve with Mary’s sunny disposition, as well as actual sunshine.
As Ayah (the only name Mary knows for her is a title referring to a south-Asian nanny or nursemaid), Belle represents Indian culture in her character without becoming a discomfiting stereotype. Her movements and Hindi songs are likely comforting memories for Mary, while aiding the otherworldly atmosphere of these adventures.
The show’s “villain” role falls to Dr. Neville, though he is more driven by misguided good intentions than greed. Hunt brings out all the conflicted feelings as he feels pressured by the demands of family and society – as well as a bit of what’s-in-this-for-me resentment.
The most compelling aspect of this production is its songs, delivered with soaring operatic grace, especially by Ewigleben’s Lily and Lipphardt’s Archibald. Gibbons belts it out excellently as well. Moore presents Dickon as a sort of shaman, singing to equal the birds he speaks with. The sheer beauty of the singing overall helps establish a feeling more romantic than spooky – even with all the ghosts – making “The Secret Garden” as inspiring as it is entertaining.
This production features a beautiful stage design by Jay Ganz, including clever representation of the garden maze. Excellent costume design is by Odle, Garner and McCabe, nicely evoking the era. Dewayne Lewis is assistant director, as well as stage manager with assistant Amy Buell.
Performances are June 4-7 at the Basile Westfield Playhouse, 220 N. Union St. (there is still road construction in the area, but the downtown is accessible). For tickets and info, go to westfieldplayhouse.org.
Plays with John & Wendy 