Dance Kaleidoscope presents fresh spin on Irving ‘Legend’

By John Lyle Belden

When a prestigious professional dance company takes on a familiar story, the results are as amazing as they are accessible to a broad audience.

In the spirit of the season, Dance Kaleidoscope presents “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,” adapted, choreographed, and directed by Joshua L. Peugh. The short story by Washington Irving, set in the years following the Revolutionary War in rural New York, has been deepened from its usual brief telling into a 75-minute program in contemporary and balletic styles. The narrative and atmosphere can get a bit frightening, so this is recommended for ages 13 and up.

Historically, the area around Tarrytown (including Sleepy Hollow) was a frequent battleground between American Continentals and the British Redcoats, joined by Hessian mercenaries, leaving many on all sides dead (including locals of varying allegiance and descendants of the original Dutch settlers). There was even a report of a Hessian officer being decapitated by a cannonball, only identified by his uniform as the head was never found.

This background is a vital part of Peugh’s production. We are frequently visited by various denizens of the spirit world, as well as the restless dead. The dancers in these roles appear in masks, often gauzy to make their faces even more haunting.

Company member Zay puts his slender body to work as the central character, Ichabod Crane. Being sensitive and superstitious, he quickly starts seeing things upon his arrival in town. Ever the academic, he banishes the dark visions with a wave of his book, but they won’t stay away long. He gains the patronage of well-to-do farmer Balt Von Tassel (Nathan Rommel) in setting up his position as schoolmaster, hoping to also gain the hand of his daughter Katrina (Julie Russel) for both her beauty and eventual inheritance (not so much a matter of greed as of honest opportunism). Katrina is flattered but not committed. She and Ichabod share an intimate dance and written love letters, but publicly she still spends time partnered with burly Brom Bones (Ryan Galloway).

Just as Crane is not all hero, Bones is not a pure villain. His jealousy over this interloper manifests more in pranks than assaults, made easy by Ichabod’s growing visions. As the days pass in what seems like a normal routine, the ghosts – including of a man Ichabod saw die in a fight that got out of hand – draw ever closer.  

At last comes the harvest festival, where Brom – dancing with a pumpkin – delivers a frightening tale. The rest of the story, you may already be familiar with. Just be sure to hold on to your hat (and what it rests on).

Our spirits of soldiers and villagers are joined by flying witches, a Woman in White (Savannah Rolfe) and even The Great He-Goat (Rommel). Filling the various roles, as well as living residents, are George Brous, Natalie Campbell, Ryan Jaffe, Gavin Kimmel, Marie Kuhns, Briah Napier, Morgan Ranney, Sarah Tylor, and Manuel Valdes. The famous climactic chase features Kimmel as The Horseman with Jaffe puppeting the frighteningly beautiful horse (designed by Nicholas Peugh).

The movement is exquisite, telling an easy-to-follow narrative while blending with the production’s overall haunted look. Historic McGowan Hall, practically across the street from the Benjamin Harrison house on North Delaware, is spooky from the moment you step inside. This continues onto the spare stage by scenic designer William Boles, with cornstalks standing sentry at the back that eventually move inward like the marching forest of Shakespeare fame. To display pride in the new nation, a giant 13-star Old Glory briefly spreads above. And as spirits can pass through walls, don’t assume there’s a “fourth wall” here. Incredible costuming was designed by Elizabeth Bourgeois. Evocative music was composed by Brandon Carson.

So – no “Trick” – here’s a “Treat:” The premiere of Joshua Peugh’s “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” continues into a second weekend! Performances are Friday through Sunday, Oct. 9-11, at 1305 N. Delaware St. Get tickets at www.dancekal.org.

A perfectly chilling part of the Indy Spooky Season (with plans to return next October), this “Sleepy Hollow” may itself become legendary.

DK explores shifting relationships, past and future

By John Lyle Belden

The power and high quality of Dance Kaleidoscope continues in artistic director Joshua Blake Carter’s second season, starting 2025 with a bold program, “Nothing is forever, darling,” at the Schott Center for the Arts on the campus of Butler University on Indy’s near-northside.

In Carter’s choreography, we encounter a wide variety of style and emotion in company premiere works. The title piece is performed to a set of songs by Rufus Wainwright, whose unique voice is a vital aspect of the atmosphere. This soundscape is given life by the movement of the dancers ranging from carefree (“Movies of Myself”) to melancholy (“Leaving for Paris”) and back again.

In “Fever Dream”, mortality and intimacy meet, choreographed by Sean Aaron Carmon to the music of Iron and Wine. In minimal, flesh-toned costumes, dancers Cody Miley and Sarah Taylor perform a stunning “nude” pas de deux.

With “Take A Gambol” the company has fun with a 60s jazz style in hip black suits and – in a first for DK – shoes! Originally created by Carter for a Chicago company in 2018, this piece includes music by Maynard Ferguson and Perry Como. Think “Fosse meets Rat Pack” for a hint at what it’s like.

For the intense second act, Carter presents the world premiere of “Shaker Loops,” with his choreography to the 1978 work of that name by composer John Adams. This could be looking to the past, inspired by sound-recording methods of its era with costuming a nod to a now-vanished religious sect, but its electronic sound, frenetic tension-building movement and stark lighting (designed by Laura E. Glover) gives a sort of sci-fi vibe. The result is a fascinating and sensual experience with dancers in perfect command of their bodies.

Along with Miley and Taylor, performers were Jonathan Cubides, Ryan Galloway, Ryan Jaffe, Courtney Jefferies, Marie Kuhns, Vivian Mickels, Natalie Nagy, Morgan Ranney, Nathan Rommel, Julie Russel, Manuel Valdes, and Zay.

This program had a single weekend, Jan. 17-19. Upcoming performances by Dance Kaleidoscope include the world premiere of “Emerge” by DK’s Jaffee & Hall Emerging Choreographer Award Winner, Tsai Hsi Hung, on March 14-16, and “Under the Covers,” featuring dance by Carter and Autumn Eckman to songs by familiar artists including Billie Eilish and Brandi Carlile, May 30-June 1. Both of these will be at The Toby at Newfields. For information and tickets, see www.dancekal.org.