KidsPlay are alive with ‘The Sound of Murder’

By John Lyle Belden

First, I must note that Wendy and I have been supporters of KidsPlay Inc. for around two decades now, going back to when I covered them for the Greenfield Daily Reporter, and Wendy would apply her famous laugh to the “Dress to Impress” preview. While this particular show has completed its one-weekend run, we encourage support of this all-volunteer program and its efforts to develop confidence, talent, and skills in children grades 3-8. And it’s open to any who can make it to rehearsals and performances, not just in Hancock County. Its impact is reflected in the numerous performers and crew in central Indiana theatre today who are KidsPlay alums, as well as those who took center stage in whatever careers they chose.

There are two KidsPlay shows a year; click their button at crazylakeacting.com or follow them on social media to learn about auditions and performances of the Spring production (TBA). As for the one we just saw:

On Broadway, there are some killer shows, really slaying them in the aisles. But when a director actually turns up dead, what do you do? Call the NYPD 42nd Precinct, where the show must go on until an arrest is made.

This is the world of “The Sound of Murder” by Don Zolidis, presented by KidsPlay Inc. of Greenfield on Nov. 13-15 at the H.J. Ricks Centre for the Arts. The crime was committed during a revue of Broadway musicals, with their characters as witnesses or suspects. Thus, they are brought in by the Police in hopes they’ll sing (as in, “confess,” but they break into song instead).

Always thinking big, KidsPlay took on another ambitious production. Given their typical large cast, director Amy Studabaker got permission from Zolidis to double the number of detectives (from two to four), and adapting the script with assistant director Rai Ortman, “we decided to ‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’ it” to hilarious effect.

Mix in more than 30 energetic, talented kids, and the result was an entertaining send-up of numerous hits, including “Chicago,” “Hamilton,” “Phantom,” “The Sound of Music” (naturally), “Sweeney Todd,” “Newsies,” “Hadestown” – even “Starlight Express.” And it wouldn’t be a musicals spoof without “Cats.” It’s like if Nickelodeon did a version of “Forbidden Broadway” – with cops.

Sargent Morales (Gigi Gunn) and detectives Abernathy (Ellie Stearns), Rivera (Asher Ortman), Boyle (Harrison Studabaker), and Diaz (Ellie Raney), with desk clerk Dina (Maggie Hanna) keeping score, attempt to question performers who won’t break character. To find a motive, their musicals are interrogated as well.

This gives us new perspectives on Maria (Aria Sudabker, who is also the Mermaid), Annie (Temi Olasakin), a Newsie (Audra Speicher), Danny Zuko (Lincoln Wheeler), Pony Boy (Oliver Lederman), the Phantom (Bennie Vaughn), Alexander Hamilton (Abby Marler), Mary Poppins (Alex Ellis), the Wicked Witch (Essie Ortman), Space Train (Drew Turner – yes, she wore roller skates), Thomas the Train (Callahan Horan), Mean Girl Heather (Josie McConnell), and even Inspector Javert (Jude Birk).

With Roxie (Lili Grzelak), Sweeney Todd (Molly Wallace), and Seymour (Oliver Lederman), we have to make certain which murder we’re talking about. On hand as counsel we have Billy Flynn (Liam Layton) and the Blonde Lawyer (Nora Smith). Wednesday Addams (Caroline Goldstein) is mainly there because she likes the vibe. Even Hades (Ace Wallace) is called in.

And there’s that Cat (Coral Watts) again!

Meanwhile, the Cell Block Girls (Brynn Brunton, Evalynn Connelly, Quinn Felver, and Nora Smith) lament the lack of snacks – some pop, or at least something to squish (uh-oh!). Elliott Holmes, Liv Frazier, and Gwen Watkins round out the cast in roles including the Von Trapp children.

The show started with its traditional dance number, a clever piece choreographed by Frances Hull that was a tribute to the characters of the game (and Broadway play) “Clue,” with a nod to “And Then There Were None.” Dancers: Aria Studabaker, Temi Olasakin, Coral Watts, Abby Marler, Jodie McConnell, Nora Smith, Evalynn Connelly, and Liv Frazier. This was one of their best show-openers.

With the aid of Amy Studabaker and the all-volunteer crew (including many proud, supportive parents) this was a truly entertaining production including great comic timing and youthful slapstick, with quite a few boys and girls in which you see that spark that means more great performances to come. Getting through the various character parodies is a hoot – starting the interrogation with “your name?” naturally launches mayhem with Mr. Hamilton. In the end there was a resolution to the overarching mystery – not entirely predictable, and appropriate while appropriately silly.

There were eight 8th-graders in this cast, marking their last year in the program before high school and other young artist opportunities. Check out KidsPlay’s Spring 2027 show to see them “graduate.”