Lucy Isles

Andersen’s own duckling-to-swan story in new musical

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By John Lyle Belden

The life of Danish author Hans Christian Andersen was quite extraordinary, resembling a novel – or perhaps, a fairy tale.

Indy Bard Fest presents “Andersen: A Fairy Tale Life,” a new musical written and directed by June McCarty Clair (with music by Derek Hakes and lyrics by John C. Clair), based on the true events of the tale-spinner’s life.

We first follow Andersen as a boy (played by Preston Blair) in the small town (at the time) of Odense on Denmark’s island of Funen – far enough from Copenhagen for it to be considered boring but close enough for royalty to visit for a quiet vacation. Raised on literature by his father (before he died) and folk tales by his illiterate mother (Lisa Anderson), the lad would sing and recite for coins on the street.

Having a good voice and endless ambition, as a teen (Grant Craig) he makes his way to Copenhagen hoping to be a performer as well as a writer. Nearly penniless, he finds his way to Jonas Collin (Mac Williams), who takes him in, and with famous voice teacher Siboni (Thom Brown), scientist H.C. Orsted (Duane Leatherman), and, reluctantly, Jonas’s son Edvard (J.B. Scoble) undergo a grand experiment to see if a low-born person with potential can bloom into a celebrated genius. Struggling at first, Andersen is sent to study under cruel schoolmaster Simon Meisling (Matthew Socey) to improve his grammar. Instead, he writes a poem which somehow makes its way into print.

This first act not only gives us an interesting biography but also provides a showcase for the talents of Blair and Craig, who get their own songs and fully realized scenes – not just used as younger faces to get to the man we know. With Craig’s charm and vocal chops, he easily portrays the star potential of the confident young Dane.

The second act brings on Andersen as a young adult, in which Matt Anderson channels his charisma into a man who came across as gangly, awkward, and eccentric, yet somehow enchanting. In these years success came easily, but happiness and a sense of belonging elude him. People love his stories, but what about the man?

This play includes references to a number of Andersen’s tales, with one even acted out by children. The songs serve the plot well – such as “Another Door,” as young Christian deals with rejection as he pursues his destiny. The second-act song “Fairy Tale Life” has showstopper potential.

Other notable performances include Rachelle Woolston as Mette the Fortune Teller, Sara Tewes as a famous ballerina, Erika Koepfer as Louise Collin, Nan Macy in brash-woman roles as usual, and Greta Shambarger as the one kindly person who doesn’t slam the door in Andersen’s face. They are joined by Beth Gibson, Derek Hakes, Emelyn Woolston, Owen Flint, Andy Burnett, Mel Burnett, Lucy Isles (Little Match Girl), Jacob Meneghini (Ugly Duckling), and Thom Johnson (Mayor of Odense).    

“Andersen: A Fairy Tale Life” is an entertaining examination of a true rags to riches story, a testament to overcoming one’s disadvantages with persistence. We get glimpses into both the author’s humor and his melancholy that informed his often-tragic writings. Ever feeling the outsider, he still lived a full and, eventually, celebrated life. The story doesn’t delve into current scholars’ controversial speculation of his sexuality, yet does portray the loneliness we know he felt.

Remaining performances are Friday through Sunday at Shelton Auditorium, 1000 W. 42nd St., Indianapolis (southwest corner of Butler University campus). For information, see indybardfest.com, or find tickets here.

CCP’s Rising Stars bring ‘Green Gables’ to life

PWJW_Indy Reviews, Stage , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

By John Lyle Belden

Carmel Community Players chose well in its summer Rising Stars production for performers ages 8 to 18, a show with plenty of youth roles: Lucy Maud Montgomery’s “Anne of Green Gables,” adapted by Joseph Robinette, directed by Amber K. Roth.

The classic turn of the 20th century story tells of Anne Shirley, an orphan sent to be adopted by siblings Matthew and Marilla Cuthbert, who had requested a boy – to help at their farm in rural Prince Edward Island – but feel persuaded to keep Anne instead. She dislikes her name but can’t get anyone to call her “Cordelia.” She hates her red hair and freckles, and anyone who mocks them. But aside from the flashes of temper, she is energetic and endlessly talkative with a wild, romantic imagination, and a positive attitude to the point of adoration. Carolyn Noneman embodies this famous free spirit perfectly, in look and tone, as though she had stepped out of the pages of Montgomery’s novel.

Aided by some “aging” makeup, high-schoolers Lincoln Everitt and Luciana Lindner embody middle-aged Matthew and Marilla with the necessary maturity, he with his wise easy nature and she with her caring fastidiousness.

Lucy Cooper is more charming than frustrating as the village of Avonlea’s biggest busybody (and neighbor of the Cuthberts), Rachel Lynde, as entertaining a gossip as one is likely to encounter.

Lilah Cross plays the well-behaved perfect counter to Anne’s force-of-nature personality as her “bosom friend” Diana Berry, while 10-year-old Lucy Isles shows great star potential as Diana’s little sister Minnie May. The Berry children live with their mother (Claire Moeller) next door to Green Gables.

Jack Levine is young Gilbert Blythe, who earns Anne’s wrath early on and spends the rest of the story hoping to win her forgiveness. Others in the cast, some in multiple roles, are Spencer Rees Bland, Amelia Fine, Mitchell Ried, Madeline Sappenfield, Greta Shambarger, Sophia Sweeney, Amelie Thibodeau, Edward Wilson, Owen Yeater, Quinn Yeater, and Eliza Graefnitz, whose roles include Diana’s Great Aunt Josephine, who finds herself charmed by Anne as well.

Various events from the book are enacted, including the “raspberry cordial” incident, the hair disaster, the game of “dares,” the Queens Academy exams, and the night Anne must save a life. My impression of this performance was that it not only tells the story wonderfully, but also could make one interested in reading the book to see what else happened.   

Roth is assisted by Melina J. Degolyer and student director and dramaturge Annabelle Pfeiffer. Hats off to the cast and crew, including Ghost Morrow, Erin Wilson, stage manager Elinah Atwell and assistant stage manager Ava McKee, for their valiant efforts at making the intimate stage of The Cat into multiple settings in frequent half-light scene changes. Roth’s stage design is also notable for its triangular rotating walls, with Montgomery’s text surrounding the scenes in the background.

While it is the Fourth of July weekend, consider spending a bit of it with a classic of Canadian literature. “Anne of Green Gables” has performances Friday and Saturday (Sunday is sold out), July 5-6, at The Cat, 254 Veterans Way, Carmel. Get tickets at thecat.biz or carmelplayers.org.