By John Lyle Belden

In the lowlands along the Mississippi River in Northeast Arkansas, they still grow cotton. We see the big bales in the fields when we drive through the area about once a year to visit relatives near Little Rock. Not much around but farmland, tiny crossroads towns, and rural churches. In pre-mechanized days, cotton farming was incredibly hard; consider what a life of growing and harvesting that crop can do to a family, to a man.

One of those men was John R. “Johnny” Cash, one of the greatest singer-songwriters to come out of the 1950s Memphis music scene. Actors Theatre of Indiana presents a fresh telling of his decades-old story in “Ring of Fire: The Music of Johnny Cash” by Richard Maltby Jr. and William Meade. The series of songs presented make this a musical journey from his boyhood farm to nearby Memphis, Tennessee, then on to Nashville and – as Johnny put it – “everywhere, man.”  

Kent M. Lewis, who has performed this show elsewhere, took on the trifecta of director, choreographer and performer, lending his tone-perfect Cash voice as primary vocalist. Brandon Alstott, who has played Cash in “Million Dollar Quartet,” easily takes on the character of young Johnny and lends his own vocal lead and harmony contributions. Matt McClure gets in some vocals as well, and while Lewis and Alstott pick acoustic guitars, McClure straps on an electric, providing the distinctive churning rhythm attributed to Cash bandmate Luther Perkins.

Multi-talented Sarah Hund fits in naturally, adept at anything with strings – especially fiddle – and helping sing and tell the story as characters including Cash’s mother as well as collaborator and eventual wife June Carter. Jordan Simmons plays stand-up bass and gets in a few lines; music director Nathan Perry also has a role, mainly performing at the piano or on accordion.

As a “jukebox musical,” revised in 2013 from the original 2006 Broadway version, this is an excellent revue for fans of old-time Country and Gospel music, as well as Cash’s hits, presented with entertaining flair that engages the audience of the intimate Studio Theater in Carmel’s Center for the Performing Arts. Don’t look for an in-depth biography, though. Maltby is reported to say that he saw in Cash’s music and life “the story of America,” and thus we get a fairly simple outline of a complicated man.

His feelings for the downtrodden are expressed in his song/poem “Man in Black” and we see them shown in his prison concerts (despite his “outlaw” image, he never did hard time himself) and frequently returning to hope in faith. He also found himself leaning on little white pills to keep up his tour schedule, he wryly confesses, but the narrative doesn’t dwell much on this aspect of his life. Still, Cash admits in a regretful tone that without raising a hand to anyone, he still hurt many who loved him.

In the end – his passing in 2003 gently hinted at – Johnny Cash leaves us wanting more, which Lewis and company provide in a brief encore with one of the Man in Black’s most fun songs.

Opening night had everyone in the full house buzzing with how much they enjoyed this show. Word will likely get around, so make a reservation to see “Ring of Fire” before the ATI run ends on Sept. 29. Get info and tickets at atistage.org or thecenterpresents.org.