By John Lyle Belden

Parts of what are now the Moon and Earth’s ocean bed once existed together, but a long-ago calamity separated them forever. Though the Moon and the Sea pull at each other, their yearning doesn’t stop the ever-increasing distance (1.5 inches a year, according to astronomers) between them.

This love story is the literal backdrop for “The Moon and the Sea,” a new musical by Douglas Lyons, with songs by Creighton Irons, presented live by Constellation Stage and Screen in Bloomington.

Singer-songwriters Charlie (Rico Lebron) and Erin (Naree Asherian) were solidly in each others’ orbit. He planned to make a visit to a seaside hideaway memorable for her, but that moment was usurped by the lovelorn spirits of Moon (Alexa Green) and Sea (Demetrio Alomar) communing in song and light.

Later, a moment of uncertainty divides our human lovers, leaving Charlie’s personal satellites – best friend Elijah (Scott Van Wye) and mother (Green) – to try to help him over the loss. Then, an open-mike night with amateur singer and “finance-bro” Doug (Jesse Townes) leads to a revelation of how much things have changed.

The pain of all-important choices reflects back and forth in song among the mortals, Moon, and the tides in an exceptional yet relatable love story.

Lebron gives us a great portrayal of a young man who confuses what he wants with what he needs, as we follow his rocky path of personal growth. Asherian’s aspirational young woman also has some learning to do, and the lessons come hard. Together in beautiful moments of song, we hear and see how wonderfully Charlie and Erin fit together, at least on stage. Townes gives us a man more noble than he would be portrayed in the Hallmark Movie version of this story; his aging frat-boy has feelings and perspective, too.

For their parts, Alomar and Green communicate passion and longing with operatic power. Under the direction of Josh Rhodes, the human and supernatural sides of this production mesh perfectly.

Van Wye makes a solid friend and gives appropriate moments of humor, as does Green as Mom and Rhonda the bartender.

The ending may surprise some, but I found it satisfying, and feel this truly new musical is worth experiencing. Performances run through June 25 at Waldron Auditorium, 122 S. Walnut St., Bloomington. For info and tickets visit seeconstellation.org.