Chekhov’s fun: Epilogue presents Durang hit

By John Lyle Belden

Celebrated American playwright Christopher Durang, notable for his comedies, gave us in 2012 an instant classic – “Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike” – inspired by the legacy of Anton Chekhov, a Russian writer at the turn of the 20th century known for more serious fare. The play is a mashup of styles, loaded with wit and belly-laughs while delivered in a mode in which everything seems fraught with meaning.

The foursome, plus two, take the stage at Epilogue Players in downtown Indy, directed by Michael and Marie Beason.

On a warm April day in Bucks County, Pa., 50-something siblings Vanya (David Johnson) and Sonia (Alyce Penry) sit with coffee and look out the windows to see if the blue heron is at the pond. They and their sister Masha (Christine Kruze) – a popular film actor – were raised by literature professors, hence their Chekhovian names. Cleaning lady Cassandra (Susan Hill) seems to live out her own legendary name, frequently declaring prophesies. “Beware of Hootie Pie!”

Masha arrives with her current lover, Spike (Logan Laflin), a hot young aspiring actor. He goes out to the pond for a swim (so much for that heron) and returns with Nina (Emily Reese Castro) a young woman from the neighboring farm who is also an adoring fan of Masha (and an aspiring actress, of course).

All six will attend a local costume ball, with their outfits arranged by Masha (or rather her assistant, Hootie Pie). As the setting doesn’t change, we mainly see the consequences the following day. There is also a reading of an unusual play that Vanya has been working on, held at the insistence of Nina – now affectionately calling him Uncle Vanya – who reads as the main character.

Chekhovian delivery actually enhances the play’s comic potential, coupled with absurdities like Cassandra’s voodoo antics, contrasting with Spike being the type of guy who thinks Chekhov only has something to do with Star Trek. Will a gun go off? One of the siblings certainly will, verbally. After all, the fate of the farmhouse and its cherry (sort of) orchard is at stake.

Hill is a hoot as the wacky prophetess pressed into making lunch. Penry is a delight as the overlooked sibling, even in her sad-sack moments (“I haven’t lived,” she moans), which makes it all the more charming when things go her way. Johnson exudes easy calm as Vanya, the peacemaker of the family, at least up to a point.

Kruze portrays Masha’s vanity as her shield against uncertainty and regret. Laflin handsomely embodies a dude who has everything except maturity. On the other hand, Castro plays Nina as an energetic youth with an old soul.

The at-home feeling set is designed by Andy and Mel Burnett, decorated by Susanne Bush. Lola Brewster is stage manager.

It’s not every show where we laugh until we hurt at people who are crying. But it’s this kind of juxtaposition that makes “Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike” fascinating company. Performances are Thursday through Sunday, Feb. 12-15, at 1849 N. Alabama St. (corner of 19th and Alabama), Indianapolis. Get tickets at epilogueplayers.com.

Leave a comment